- Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg appeared to criticize Apple on Wednesday in the companies’ ongoing battle over privacy.
- The social-networking company won’t set up data centers in countries with poor human-rights records, he said.
- That stance has caused it to lose business, but it’s a “tradeoff we’re willing to make,” he said.
- Zuckerberg didn’t mention Apple, but it seemed clear that he was contrasting Facebook with the iPhone maker.
- Apple last year set up a data center in China so it could continue to offer its iCloud services there.
Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg on Wednesday took a thinly veiled jab at Apple by casting the social network as a defender of privacy that is willing to resist cooperating with governments that have poor human-rights records.
The comments, which were made in a lengthy blog post by Zuckerberg on Wednesday, made an implicit comparison between his company and Apple’s controversial practices in China and marked the latest flare-up in a long-running battle between the two tech giants over consumer privacy.
The social-networking company has sacrificed business to protect its customers, Zuckerberg said. Facebook has intentionally chosen not to put its servers in countries that have poor track records on human rights, even though those decisions have meant that it can’t offer its services in those places, he said.
“That’s a tradeoff we’re willing to make,” Zuckerberg said. “I think it’s important for the future of the internet and privacy that our industry continues to hold firm against storing people’s data in places where it won’t be secure.”
Zuckerberg didn’t mention Apple by name, but the contrast he was drawing between his company and the iPhone maker was clear to people who have been following the feud between the two. Last year, Apple set up a data center China to host the local version of its iCloud online services there in response to new laws. The data center is being operated by a Chinese company, which has raised alarms among privacy advocates concerned that it would allow the Chinese government to more easily get access to its citizens’ personal data.
Facebook, by comparison, has been blocked in China since 2009 and doesn’t have any data centers there.
The statement from Zuckerberg “is a massive shot across [Apple CEO] Tim Cook’s bow,” Alex Stamos, Facebook’s former cybersecurity chief, said in a tweet. “Expect to hear a lot about [iCloud] and China every time Cook is sanctimonious.”
7) The “Secure Data Storage” section is a massive shot across Tim Cook’s bow. Expect to hear a lot about iCLoud and China every time Cook is sanctimonious.
In other news, Zuck has clearly given up on entering China, as these changes makes that impossible. Good. pic.twitter.com/xvkdS4kN3b
— Alex Stamos (@alexstamos) March 6, 2019
Zuckerberg and Cook have been fighting about privacy
Cook has tried to position Apple as the tech industry’s paragon for privacy protection and has sought to compare his company’s practices with those of its rivals. Unlike Facebook, Google, and other online giants, Apple isn’t dependent on advertising and limits the amount of data it collects from users of its devices and services. It also emphasizes the security of its phones and services, including iMessage.
As part of his privacy push, Cook has repeatedly criticized Facebook’s privacy practices, particularly in the wake of the social-networking giant’s Cambridge Analytica scandal last year. Just last week, at Apple’s annual shareholder meeting, he again seemed to criticize Facebook, saying that the practice of collecting detailed information about consumers and using it to divide them from each other “should not exist.”
For his part, Zuckerberg has bristled at the criticism and even ordered Facebook executives to ditch their iPhones for Android devices.
But both sides have notable shortcomings in their arguments. Facebook and Zuckerberg have repeatedly tried to court Chinese officials and have explored numerous ways of offering their services there. Apple, meanwhile, does collect some data on its users for services such as its Siri voice assistant and its Maps applications, and it gets billions of dollars in revenue each year from Google for making the search giant its default search service on the iPhone.